"How Are You Mine?" is a song that pays homage to love, reflecting on the incredulous joy of finding someone who elevates your life. It questions in disbelief how someone so wonderful could come into your life, especially from the perspective of someone accustomed to self-deprecation. This persona grapples with the challenge of embracing public happiness, which seems out of character. Notably, this is one of the oldest songs on the record, marking Ben's initial foray into more positive songwriting. It captures the essence of love's transformative power, standing in contrast to his earlier, more melancholic themes. The song embodies the sentiment that love can indeed conquer all.